Frozen Peppermint Cream Pie: The Ultimate Festive Dessert with a Kick

As the holiday season approaches, our thoughts often turn to comforting flavors and festive treats. Among these, the invigorating taste of peppermint always stands out. While many enjoy peppermint in candies or hot beverages, have you ever considered it as the star of a creamy, dreamy pie? This Frozen Peppermint Cream Pie is not just any dessert; it’s a celebration of mint and chocolate, elevated by the smooth, sweet kick of Peppermint Schnapps. Peppermint Schnapps is a clear, mint-flavored liqueur known for its syrupy consistency and potent mint essence, which is notably stronger than that of Crème de Menthe. It’s a popular choice for holiday cocktails, enriching hot chocolate, and crafting chilled festive shots. Intrigued by its potential, I set out to incorporate this distinct liqueur into a peppermint cream pie. After several delightful trials and adjustments, the recipe you’ll find here emerged as the unequivocal family favorite, capturing the perfect balance of cool mint, rich chocolate, and a hint of boozy warmth.

Jump to Recipe

Crafting the Perfect No-Bake Oreo Pie Crust

The foundation of any great pie is its crust, and for this Frozen Peppermint Cream Pie, we opt for a rich chocolate cookie crust that perfectly complements the cool mint filling. When I first embarked on this recipe, I experimented with readily available store-bought Oreo-flavored crusts, which offered convenience and a suitable size for the filling. The combination of chocolate and mint is, of course, a timeless classic, and these pre-made crusts delivered on flavor. However, a significant drawback quickly became apparent: these specific Oreo-flavored “ready-crusts” aren’t always easy to find, especially when you crave this particular dessert. This led me to develop a reliable, equally delicious, and incredibly simple homemade alternative: a no-bake crumb crust made from crushed Oreos and melted butter. Not only is this homemade crust consistently accessible, but it also allows for a richer, more robust chocolate flavor and a perfectly crisp texture that stands up beautifully to the creamy filling. Using whole Oreos, including the cream filling, adds an extra layer of sweetness and binds the crumbs wonderfully, making it a truly decadent base for our peppermint delight.

Essential Ingredients for Your Luscious Peppermint Pie Filling

With the switch to a homemade, standard 9-inch pie crust, the filling needed to be perfected to achieve that ideal creamy, yet firm, consistency. Our new and improved filling calls for a thoughtful blend of ingredients, each playing a crucial role in creating the ultimate frozen peppermint experience. You’ll need a package of instant vanilla or white chocolate pudding mix to provide a smooth, creamy base, combined with whole milk for richness. The star of the show, Peppermint Schnapps, infuses the filling with its signature minty zing and a subtle alcoholic warmth, making this pie truly special for adult gatherings. We also incorporate luscious, packaged fudge sauce, which adds a layer of deep chocolate flavor that perfectly marries with the mint. An important setting agent in this recipe is marshmallows, providing a delightful chewiness and helping the pie hold its shape without becoming rock-hard when frozen. Finally, the use of Cool Whip (or any brand of frozen whipped topping) is absolutely essential. While I initially attempted to use heavy whipping cream, for a frozen pie of this nature, Cool Whip consistently delivers a lighter, more stable texture that resists crystallization and ensures a perfectly scoopable dessert every time. Save your heavy whipping cream for other desserts where its rich, dairy texture can truly shine; for this pie, Cool Whip is the undisputed champion.

The Magic of Marshmallows: Setting Your Peppermint Pie

When it comes to setting cream pies, many recipes default to gelatin for its reliable gelling properties. However, for this particular Frozen Peppermint Cream Pie, marshmallows are the secret ingredient that truly makes a difference. Not only do they provide a wonderful, slightly chewy texture that contrasts beautifully with the smooth filling, but they are also incredibly easy to work with, often less intimidating than handling powdered gelatin. You’ll need 100 grams of marshmallows for this recipe. If you’re using mini marshmallows, this translates to approximately 2 ½ cups. Should you only have the larger, standard-sized marshmallows on hand, don’t worry – 100 grams will still work perfectly, simply requiring a bit more patience as they melt. The melted marshmallows, combined with a touch of butter, create a stable yet delightfully soft base for the minty filling, ensuring your pie sets beautifully while maintaining its creamy, melt-in-your-mouth quality even after being frozen. This choice not only simplifies the process but also enhances the overall sensory experience of the pie.

Simple Steps for Making This Irresistible Peppermint Pie

Creating this Frozen Peppermint Cream Pie is a straightforward and rewarding process, perfect for home bakers of all skill levels. While I may add some visual step-by-step photos in the future, here’s a comprehensive rundown to guide you through each stage. From preparing the crunchy Oreo crust to freezing the luscious mint filling, these steps ensure a perfect pie every time. Pay close attention to cooling times, as they are crucial for achieving the ideal texture and preventing your pie from becoming too soft or runny.

• Prepare the Chocolate Crust: Begin by making a quick no-bake pie crust. Crush your Oreos finely, then mix them thoroughly with melted butter until well combined. Press this mixture firmly into a 9-inch pie dish, creating an even layer. Pop it into the freezer for about 20 minutes to allow it to firm up while you prepare the next components. Once chilled, retrieve the crust and spread a layer of your favorite fudge sauce evenly across the bottom. This adds an extra dimension of chocolatey goodness.
• Melt Marshmallows and Infuse with Peppermint: In a small saucepan, gently melt the marshmallows and butter together over low heat, stirring constantly until completely smooth. Once melted, remove the pan from the heat and stir in the Peppermint Schnapps. It’s important to let this mixture cool down. Allowing it to cool to at least lukewarm, or ideally room temperature, prevents it from cooking the pudding when combined.
• Prepare the Pudding Base: In a separate, large mixing bowl, whisk together one cup of cold whole milk and the package of instant pudding mix (white chocolate or vanilla work best). Continue whisking until the pudding thickens to a creamy consistency, typically taking a couple of minutes.
• Combine and Chill the Filling: Now, carefully fold the slightly cooled peppermint-marshmallow mixture into the prepared pudding mixture. At this stage, add a few drops of red food coloring to achieve a lovely pale pink hue – remember, it will lighten further when you incorporate the whipped topping. Chill this combined mixture in the refrigerator for at least 30 minutes, or until it becomes thick enough to hold its shape when folded. This chilling step is vital for the pie’s final texture. Once thickened, gently fold in about two-thirds of an 8-ounce tub of non-dairy whipped topping (like Cool Whip) until just combined, being careful not to overmix and deflate the topping. Transfer this light and airy peppermint filling into your prepared pie crust and smooth the top.
• Freeze and Garnish: Place the pie in the freezer for a minimum of four hours, or preferably overnight, to allow it to set completely. This ensures it will be firm enough to slice cleanly. Shortly before you plan to serve, retrieve the pie from the freezer. Sprinkle generously with crushed peppermints or festive peppermint bark over the entire surface. For an elegant finish, pipe the remaining whipped topping around the edges or create a beautiful swirl in the center.

Storing and Serving Your Frozen Peppermint Pie

One of the best features of this Frozen Peppermint Cream Pie is its excellent freezer-friendly nature, making it an ideal make-ahead dessert for busy holiday seasons. For optimal freshness and texture, this pie is best stored in the freezer, wrapped tightly in plastic wrap or placed in an airtight container to prevent freezer burn. The alcohol from the Peppermint Schnapps and the marshmallows in the filling work synergistically to prevent the pie from freezing into a solid, impenetrable block, ensuring it remains delightfully scoopable. However, because it is a frozen pie, you’ll want to allow it to sit at room temperature for approximately 15-20 minutes before attempting to slice and serve. This brief thawing period will soften it just enough to achieve perfect, clean slices and a wonderfully creamy consistency that melts in your mouth. If you find your Oreo crust is a bit stubborn in the pie dish, a quick trick is to briefly dip the bottom of the pie dish into warm water for a few seconds. This will gently loosen the crust, making it much easier to remove the slices without breakage. Enjoy this refreshing treat for up to a week in the freezer, ensuring a delightful dessert is always on hand for unexpected guests or a spontaneous craving.

• Peppermint Bark for The Holidays: A Classic Treat
• White Chocolate Peppermint Pistachio Bars: A Unique Combination
• Milk Chocolate Peppermint Ice Cream Crunch Cake: Decadent Layers
• Really Good Carrot Cake: A Timeless Favorite
• Peppermint Cake Roll: An Elegant Holiday Dessert

Recipe Card