Unexpectedly Delicious: The Creamy Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie You Have to Try!
Prepare yourself for a dessert revelation! This **Chocolate Butterfinger Pie** might just be one of the most delightfully surprising recipes you’ll ever encounter. At its heart, it’s a wonderfully easy pie, featuring luscious layers of rich chocolate and a creamy, crunchy Butterfinger-flavored filling. But here’s the twist – it achieves its incredible smoothness and unique texture thanks to a secret ingredient: silken tofu. Yes, tofu! This might sound unconventional, and honestly, at one point, I even removed this recipe from the blog, thinking it was too ‘out there’ and no one would dare to try it. To my absolute surprise and joy, someone did!
By popular demand and a heartwarming request, this much-loved (and once-hidden) recipe is officially back! If you’re an adventurous baker, or simply looking for a fantastic way to incorporate silken tofu and Cool Whip into a truly unforgettable dessert, you’ve come to the right place. This pie proves that sometimes, the most unexpected combinations lead to the most delicious results. Get ready to experience a dessert that is not only incredibly simple to prepare but also shockingly delicious and remarkably light, despite its indulgent flavors. It’s time to rediscover a pie that challenges perceptions and satisfies sweet cravings in the most wonderful way.
Jump to Recipe
Why This Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie Will Surprise and Delight You
You might be wondering, “Tofu in a pie? Really?” And my answer is a resounding “Yes!” This **Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie** isn’t just another dessert; it’s a culinary experience that redefines what a pie can be. The silken tofu is completely undetectable in flavor, yet it lends an incredibly smooth, almost mousse-like texture to the chocolate layer, making it lusciously creamy without being overly heavy. This unexpected ingredient transforms a potentially dense dessert into something surprisingly light and elegant.
Beyond the tofu, the pie boasts a symphony of textures and flavors. You get the classic, crumbly, and slightly salty crunch of an Oreo crust, which perfectly complements the rich, deep notes of the chocolate filling. Then comes the star of the show: the Butterfinger layer. Crushed Butterfinger candy bars are folded into a creamy, dreamy concoction, delivering that signature peanut-buttery, crispy, and slightly sticky goodness that Butterfinger enthusiasts adore. The contrast between the silky chocolate, the crunchy candy, and the buttery crust is simply irresistible. This pie is a celebration of contrasting elements working in perfect harmony, creating a dessert that is both comforting and exciting. It’s truly a must-try for anyone seeking an easy yet impressive treat.
Ingredient Spotlight: Understanding the Magic Behind This Unique Pie
Every great recipe hinges on its ingredients, and this **Creamy Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie** is no exception. Let’s dive into why each component plays a crucial role in creating this unexpectedly delicious dessert:
Silken Tofu: The Secret to Unrivaled Creaminess
This is where the magic happens! **Silken tofu** is not your average block of tofu. It has a much higher water content and an incredibly smooth, custard-like consistency, making it ideal for blending into creamy sauces, smoothies, and, in this case, a pie filling. When processed, it becomes virtually flavorless, taking on the taste of the chocolate and vanilla, while providing a remarkably rich, smooth, and stable base. It eliminates the need for heavy creams or large amounts of butter in the chocolate layer, contributing to a lighter mouthfeel without sacrificing an ounce of decadence. Ensure you select the “silken” variety, as firmer tofus will not yield the desired smooth texture.
Butterfinger Candy Bars: The Crunchy, Peanut-Buttery Heart
What would a Butterfinger Pie be without actual Butterfinger bars? These iconic candy bars provide the namesake flavor and essential crunch that elevates this pie from great to unforgettable. The combination of crispy peanut butter layers coated in chocolate is a textural and flavor powerhouse. When crushed and folded into the cream cheese mixture, they create delightful pockets of sweetness and crunch, offering a fantastic contrast to the smooth chocolate layer. Don’t skimp on these; they are crucial for the authentic Butterfinger experience.
Oreo Cookies: The Classic, Easy Crust
The foundation of our pie is a simple yet effective **Oreo cookie crust**. Oreos, with their distinct chocolatey flavor and creamy filling, make an ideal base that requires minimal effort. When crushed and mixed with melted butter, they form a sturdy, flavorful crust that bakes up quickly and holds the rich fillings beautifully. This classic choice ensures a universally loved base that everyone can appreciate.
Cool Whip: The Convenient Cloud of Sweetness
For ease and a reliably light texture, **Cool Whip** is an excellent choice for the whipped topping. It’s stable and provides a sweet, airy contrast to the dense chocolate and crunchy Butterfinger layers. If you prefer a more homemade touch, you can certainly whip your own fresh cream, adding a touch of sugar and vanilla, for a richer, less processed alternative. Both options work wonderfully, so choose what best suits your preference and time constraints.
Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chips: The Rich, Indulgent Base
Good quality **semi-sweet chocolate chips** are vital for the deep, satisfying chocolate flavor of the pie’s first layer. They provide the richness and intensity that balances the sweetness of the Butterfinger and Cool Whip. Melting them carefully ensures a smooth integration with the tofu, creating a velvety ganache-like layer that forms the base of this extraordinary dessert.
Recipe
Chocolate Butterfinger Pie
Cookie Madness
Pin Recipe
Ingredients
- 12-15 Oreo cookies
- 2 tablespoons butter melted
- 1 12.6 oz package silken tofu (make sure you use the kind that says Silken)
- 1 ½ teaspoon vanilla extract divided
- 1 12 oz package chocolate chips, semi-sweet
- 4 ounces cream cheese softened
- ¼ cup granulated sugar
- 1 tablespoon butterscotch flavored instant pudding OR I think 1 tab. peanut butter would work
- 2 Butterfinger Candy Bars crushed
- 1 8 oz container Cool Whip, thawed (or you can whip 1 cup of cream, of course)
Instructions
-
Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Grease a 9 inch deep dish pie plate.
-
Place Oreos in food processor and process into crumbs. Add melted butter. Empty Oreo/butter mixture into pie plate and press into bottom. Bake for 8-10 minutes.
-
Clean food processor bowl and process tofu until it is very smooth. Add 1 teaspoon of the vanilla.
-
Melt chocolate chips in microwave or over stove. Add melted chocolate to tofu and process until smooth. Spoon into baked pie crust.
-
In a mixing bowl, beat cream cheese, sugar, remaining ½ teaspoon vanilla and pudding mix (or peanut butter) until creamy and smooth. Fold in crushed Butterfingers. Fold in half of the whipped topping. Spoon over center of pie, leaving a border of about ½ inch.
-
Place remaining whipped topping in a zipper bag, cut off bottom corner, pipe remaining Cool Whip around edges. Chill for at least 4 hours.
-
Makes 10 servings
Getting Started: Tips for a Perfect Tofu Butterfinger Pie
Even though this **Easy Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie** is relatively simple, a few tips can ensure your pie turns out absolutely perfect:
- For the Oreo Crust: Make sure your Oreos are finely crushed to create a cohesive crust. A food processor works best for this. Press the mixture firmly into the pie plate; this compact base prevents crumbling when sliced. Baking the crust for a short time helps set it beautifully.
- Silken Tofu Smoothness: The key to a non-tofu-tasting chocolate layer is thorough processing. Blend the silken tofu until it’s incredibly smooth, with no discernible lumps. This step is crucial for achieving that desirable mousse-like consistency.
- Melting Chocolate: Whether you use a microwave or a double boiler, melt your chocolate chips slowly and carefully to avoid scorching. Overheated chocolate can become grainy or seize. Stir until just smooth.
- Cream Cheese Mixture: Ensure your cream cheese is softened to room temperature. This allows it to beat smoothly with the sugar and vanilla, preventing lumps in your Butterfinger layer.
- Folding, Not Beating: When incorporating the crushed Butterfingers and whipped topping into the cream cheese mixture, use a gentle folding technique. This preserves the airy texture of the whipped topping and keeps the Butterfinger pieces intact for that satisfying crunch.
- Chilling is Key: Do not rush the chilling process! The pie needs at least 4 hours (and ideally longer, or even overnight) in the refrigerator to properly set. This ensures firm, clean slices and allows the flavors to meld beautifully.
Variations and Customizations for Your Butterfinger Pie
While this **Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie** recipe is fantastic as is, don’t hesitate to get creative and tailor it to your taste. Here are a few ideas to inspire you:
- Crust Alternatives: If Oreos aren’t your favorite, consider a graham cracker crust, a shortbread cookie crust, or even a pretzel crust for a sweet and salty twist.
- Chocolate Choices: Experiment with different types of chocolate chips. Dark chocolate will give a more intense flavor, while milk chocolate will create a sweeter, creamier layer. You could even use white chocolate for a lighter color and different flavor profile.
- Pudding Mix Flavor: The recipe suggests butterscotch instant pudding or peanut butter for the Butterfinger layer. Feel free to use another flavor of instant pudding mix, such as vanilla or even a different nut butter if you’re experimenting with other candy bar additions.
- Whipped Topping: As mentioned, homemade whipped cream is always an option for a richer taste than Cool Whip. You can sweeten it with powdered sugar and a dash more vanilla.
- Extra Crunch: For even more texture, sprinkle additional crushed Butterfinger pieces on top just before serving, or add a drizzle of melted chocolate or caramel sauce.
- Nut-Free Option: If you need a nut-free version, replace Butterfinger bars with a different crispy, chocolate-covered candy bar and omit the peanut butter substitution for the pudding mix.
Storage and Make-Ahead Tips
This **Creamy Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie** is an excellent make-ahead dessert, perfect for parties or busy weeks. You can prepare the entire pie a day or two in advance. Store it covered loosely with plastic wrap in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days. For longer storage, slices of the pie can be frozen for up to one month. Wrap individual slices tightly in plastic wrap and then in foil, then thaw in the refrigerator overnight before serving for the best texture.
Frequently Asked Questions About This Tofu Pie
Let’s address some common questions you might have about this unique **Tofu Chocolate Butterfinger Pie**:
- Can I taste the tofu in the pie? Absolutely not! When silken tofu is thoroughly processed and combined with strong flavors like chocolate and vanilla, its mild taste is completely masked. It primarily contributes to the pie’s incredibly smooth and creamy texture, making it undetectable to even the most discerning palate.
- Is this pie a healthier alternative? While it’s still a dessert, the inclusion of silken tofu in the chocolate layer can make it feel lighter and less rich than a traditional pie made with heavy cream and butter. It offers a unique texture and can be a good option for those looking for something a bit different, though it’s still an indulgent treat.
- Can I make this pie vegan? With a few substitutions, yes! You would need to use vegan Oreo cookies (some brands are accidentally vegan), a vegan butter alternative for the crust, vegan semi-sweet chocolate chips, and a plant-based whipped topping like coconut whipped cream or a store-bought vegan Cool Whip alternative. Ensure your cream cheese is also vegan.
- What kind of Butterfinger bars should I use? Regular, full-sized Butterfinger candy bars work perfectly. You’ll crush them yourself, so you don’t need to look for pre-crushed varieties.
- How do I ensure my pie sets properly? The key is adequate chilling time. Allow the pie to chill for a minimum of 4 hours, but ideally, overnight. This gives all the layers time to firm up and meld, resulting in clean slices and a perfectly set texture.
This **Chocolate Butterfinger Pie with Tofu** truly stands out as a unique and surprisingly delightful dessert. It’s a testament to how creative ingredient choices can lead to extraordinary flavors and textures. Whether you’re a long-time Butterfinger fan or simply curious to try something new, this pie promises a creamy, crunchy, and utterly satisfying experience. Give it a try, share it with friends, and prepare to amaze everyone with its unexpected deliciousness. Enjoy every single bite of this amazing creation!