The Ultimate Guide to Baking Thin & Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies: A Modernized Recipe for Perfection
While my heart often yearns for the nostalgic comfort of thick, crumbly peanut butter cookies, there’s a unique delight to be found in a thin, delightfully chewy counterpart. This recipe, initially inspired by Doris Reynolds’ contribution in “Food Writers’ Favorite Cookies,” has undergone a careful evolution in my kitchen. What began as a quest for a good cookie transformed into a dedicated journey to perfect the ideal thin and chewy texture, resulting in a cookie that is not only delicious on its own but also excels as a foundational component for gourmet ice cream sandwiches.
My initial attempt at this recipe, first shared in 2005, yielded delicious cookies, but they didn’t quite hit the mark on chewiness. The dough back then also demanded considerable chilling before it could be shaped with ease. Over the years, this recipe became a personal project. I re-tested it countless times, experimenting with subtle variations—omitting milk, adjusting quantities—all while striving to honor the essence of the original “food writer’s favorite” concept without a complete overhaul. The goal was always to achieve that perfect balance: undeniably chewy, yet wonderfully soft, and crucially, remaining tender even after freezing. I’m thrilled to say that after years of refinement, these thin and chewy peanut butter cookies now meet every expectation. They maintain their delightful softness in the freezer, making them truly perfect for creating extraordinary homemade ice cream sandwiches.
Adapting to Modern Ingredients: Why Old Recipes Need Updates
You might wonder why a perfectly good recipe from a reputable food writer would require so many adjustments. The simple truth is that the culinary landscape evolves, and so do our ingredients. What was readily available and standard decades ago might be subtly different today, necessitating tweaks to classic recipes for optimal results. For instance, the butter commonly found in stores now typically contains around 80% fat, a slight decrease from the approximate 82% fat content it once held. This seemingly minor difference can profoundly impact dough consistency, often leading to a looser texture. This is likely a key reason why my modernized recipe requires less milk than its original iteration. Furthermore, even seemingly universal ingredients like eggs can vary. Some speculate that USA-produced eggs today might have a slightly higher ratio of white to yolk, which again affects moisture and binding properties in baking. These are just a couple of examples, but a multitude of ingredients, from flours to sugars, have undergone subtle changes that can throw off the delicate balance of older recipes. Understanding these shifts is vital for achieving consistent, delicious results in contemporary baking.
Creating Delicious Gluten-Free Thin & Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies
The culinary world has also seen tremendous advancements in specialized ingredients, none more impactful for many than the widespread availability of high-quality gluten-free flour blends. For those seeking a gluten-free option, I have fantastic news: this thin and chewy peanut butter cookie recipe adapts exceptionally well to gluten-free alternatives! You can achieve the same wonderful chewiness and flavor simply by swapping out the all-purpose flour for an equal gram amount of your favorite gluten-free 1:1 flour blend. Many brands, like Cup4Cup, are specifically formulated to mimic the properties of wheat flour, making them a seamless substitute in recipes like this. To take the chewiness to an even higher level in your gluten-free batch, consider a slight adjustment to the sugar ratio. Instead of an even split, opt for ¾ cup of brown sugar and ¼ cup of granulated sugar. The increased brown sugar contributes more moisture and helps maintain that desirable soft, chewy texture, which can sometimes be a challenge with gluten-free flours. This ensures that everyone, regardless of dietary preferences, can enjoy these irresistible chewy peanut butter cookies.
The Modernized Recipe: Key Adjustments for Superior Texture and Flavor
After numerous tests and refinements, I’m excited to share the modernized version of this beloved recipe, meticulously crafted to ensure maximum chewiness and depth of flavor. Each adjustment was made with a specific goal in mind, contributing to the overall excellence of these cookies. Here’s a detailed look at the enhancements:
- Browned Unsalted Butter: I transitioned from salted to unsalted butter, primarily for better control over the salt content in the finished cookie. The game-changer, however, was browning the butter. This simple step reduces the butter’s moisture content while simultaneously infusing it with a rich, nutty, caramelized flavor that elevates the entire cookie. Be sure to cool the browned butter slightly before incorporating it into the mix to prevent cooking the eggs.
- Reduced Milk: As mentioned earlier, with changes in butter fat content and my pursuit of a specific texture, reducing the milk was crucial. The original recipe called for a bit more liquid, which sometimes resulted in a less chewy cookie. The current minimal amount (and only if the dough feels too stiff) helps maintain a denser, more pliable dough that bakes up perfectly chewy.
- A Touch of Vanilla Extract: Vanilla is a classic complement to peanut butter, and adding a small amount significantly enhances the overall aroma and flavor profile, bringing a warm, inviting quality to each bite.
- Balanced Sugar Ratios: The original recipe’s sugar profile was good, but I’ve tweaked it to ensure optimal texture. You can use either light or dark brown sugar based on your preference and what you have on hand. Light brown sugar offers a slightly milder molasses flavor, while dark brown sugar provides a richer, deeper note. Both contribute to the cookie’s chewiness and moisture retention, working in harmony with the granulated sugar to create that ideal balance of soft interior and slightly crisp edge.
- Cookie Size and Yield: For consistent baking and a more manageable cookie, I now recommend using a small cookie scoop or about a tablespoon of dough per cookie. This yields approximately 48 cookies, a slight reduction from the original 60 smaller cookies. This size ensures each cookie bakes evenly to that desirable thin and chewy state.
- Optional Spices: While optional, a hint of ground ginger or cinnamon can add an extra layer of warmth and complexity, complementing the peanut butter beautifully without overpowering it.
These adjustments collectively transform a good recipe into a truly exceptional one, delivering thin and chewy peanut butter cookies that are reliably perfect every time. If your preference leans towards a chewy cookie that’s noticeably thicker and more substantial, I wholeheartedly recommend exploring my recipe for Peanut Butter Jumbos. However, for that delicate balance of thinness and chew, this modernized recipe is your ultimate go-to.
More Delicious Cookie Madness Recipes
If you’re looking for more baking inspiration or other delightful cookie recipes to try, here are a few favorites from my collection:
- Espresso Fudge Cups with Kahlua Glaze
- Double Chocolate Thin Biscotti
- Crisp and Thin Peanut Butter Cookies
- Chewy Brownies Made in One Bowl
- Easy and Good Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Recipe
Thin & Chewy Peanut Butter Cookies
Anna
Pin Recipe
Ingredients
- ½ cup unsalted butter browned and cooled slightly (114 grams)
- ¾ teaspoon salt or ¼ teaspoon if using salted butter
- 1 cup chunky peanut butter, sweetened type (260 grams)
- ¾ cup granulated sugar (150 gams)
- ¾ cup light or dark brown sugar (150 grams)
- 2 large eggs room temperature
- 1 cup all-purpose flour (135 grams)
- ¼ teaspoon baking soda
- ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
- ¼ teaspoon ground ginger or cinnamon
- ½ tablespoon milk, use only if dough seems stiff
Instructions
-
Preheat oven to 325°F (163°C). Line baking sheets with parchment paper.
-
In a mixing bowl, beat together the melted and cooled browned butter, salt, and peanut butter until smooth.
-
Add sugars and beat until creamy, then beat in eggs and vanilla until just combined.
-
Whisk together flour, baking soda, and spice (if using). Stir into peanut butter mixture until incorporated. Dough should be soft and scoopable. If it feels too stiff, you can add the tiny splash of milk.
-
Scoop rounded teaspoonfuls (or use a small cookie scoop) onto baking sheets. Flatten slightly with a fork in a criss-cross pattern.
-
Bake 11-13 minutes, until edges are set and centers are still soft. For chewier cookies, pull early; for crispier edges, bake toward 13 minutes.
-
Cool on sheets 5 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack.
Notes