Easy Boxed Brownie Mix Caramel Brownies: The Ultimate Chewy & Fudgy Recipe

Craving the luxurious taste of homemade caramel brownies but short on time? You’re in luck! For years, I perfected a scratch caramel brownie recipe, but recently, I’ve embraced the convenience and consistent results of boxed brownie mixes. The mission: to create truly sensational caramel brownies using a simple mix. The result? These incredibly thick, fudgy, and intensely satisfying 8-inch square pan brownies, featuring a generous layer of gooey caramel and crunchy pecans running right through the center. While delicious on their own, a sprinkle of flaky sea salt is highly recommended to elevate the flavors and add a delightful contrast.

Choosing Your Brownie Mix for Perfect Caramel Layers

While you can certainly adapt this recipe to most brownie mixes, my extensive testing focused on two popular brands: Duncan Hines Chewy and Aldi’s Specially Selected, which offers a robust, Ghirardelli-like chocolate flavor at a budget-friendly price. Both mixes produced fantastic results, though I found their ideal bake times varied slightly. Perfecting the timing was key to achieving that ideal balance of fudgy brownie and set caramel without overbaking.

The brownies pictured below, with their distinctively gooey center, were made with Duncan Hines Chewy. I intentionally underbaked them a touch to test the limits, and while they were incredibly tasty, a slightly longer bake would have resulted in a firmer, yet still fudgy, texture. This experience taught me valuable lessons about the two-stage baking process essential for these layered treats.

And here, behold the rich, dark beauty of the brownies made with the Specially Selected brownie mix. As you can see, these brownies boast a deeper, more intense chocolate hue, promising a profound cocoa experience.

These were the primary brands of boxed brownie mix I tested for this particular caramel brownie recipe. However, my baking journey with boxed mixes is far from over! I’m eagerly anticipating trying this method again with Betty Crocker, another beloved brand known for its reliable brownie mixes, to see how it performs with our luscious caramel layer.

The Best Caramels for Your Boxed Brownie Mix Creation

The heart of these brownies lies in their decadent caramel filling. Choosing the right caramel is crucial for achieving the perfect gooey, yet set, consistency. For my first batch, I successfully used Kraft Caramel Bits, combining them with 5 teaspoons of heavy cream to create a smooth, pourable sauce. These bits melt beautifully and hold their structure well during the second bake.

For the subsequent batch, specifically with the Specially Selected brownie mix, I opted for 23 Werther’s Original Chewy Caramels, again with 5 teaspoons of cream. Both types of caramel melted without a hitch and maintained their integrity throughout the baking process. I noted that the Werther’s caramel filling yielded a slightly softer, more melt-in-your-mouth texture, which some might prefer for an extra-gooey experience. Feel free to use your favorite brand of soft, unwrapped caramels or even a homemade caramel sauce, ensuring it’s thick enough to hold its shape once cooled.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Make Caramel Brownies with Brownie Mix

This recipe is surprisingly easy, making it perfect for bakers of all skill levels. While bake times might vary slightly depending on your chosen brownie mix and oven, the good news is that it’s quite forgiving. Even if they’re a little underbaked (hello, ultra-fudgy!) or slightly overbaked (still delicious!), these brownies are guaranteed to be a hit.

1. **Prepare the Base Layer:** After mixing your brownie batter according to package directions, spread about a heaping cup (approximately 10 oz if you’re using a kitchen scale for precision) into your prepared 8-inch square pan. This initial, thin layer will bake for approximately 18-20 minutes until just set. It’s absolutely crucial that this base layer cools completely before you add the caramel. For best results, allow it to cool on the counter for 30 minutes, then transfer it to the freezer for about 15 minutes. This ensures the base is thoroughly chilled, preventing the caramel from becoming too runny and over-baking during the second round.
2. **Melt the Caramel:** In a microwave-safe bowl, combine your chosen caramels (Kraft bits or Werther’s) with the heavy cream. Heat on a lower power setting (e.g., 50%) in short increments, stirring well after each interval. This gentle approach prevents the caramel from scorching. It should only take a couple of minutes total, depending on your microwave’s power. Once smooth and creamy, stir in your chopped and toasted pecans. The pecans add a wonderful crunch and nutty flavor that complements the sweet caramel perfectly.
3. **Layer the Caramel:** Once your brownie base is completely cold and firm, spread the warm, melted caramel mixture evenly over it. Be sure to leave about a ½-inch border around the edges to prevent the caramel from oozing out during the final bake. The cold brownie base will help the caramel set quickly. If it seems too soft, a brief chill in the refrigerator or freezer will help it firm up.
4. **Add the Top Layer & Final Bake:** Carefully spread the remaining brownie batter over the now-firm caramel layer. This can be a bit tricky, so work gently from the center outwards. To ensure even baking and prevent the edges from drying out while the thick center cooks through, bake these brownies at a slightly lower temperature of 325°F (160°C). This extended, gentler bake allows the brownies to cook more evenly. My second bake typically takes around 45 minutes. Don’t be fooled if they still seem a bit soft when you first pull them out; an instant-read thermometer should register around 200-210°F (93-99°C) in the center, indicating they are done. They will continue to set as they cool, resulting in that perfect fudgy texture. And don’t forget to sprinkle with sea salt if you have some!

These related recipes from my collection are perfect if you’re looking for more caramel-filled inspiration:

• (These are the scratch ones I usually make) Caramel Filled Brownies
• Pecan Pie with Melted Caramels
• Caramel Filled Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Bars (Small Batch)
• Pecan Caramel Bar Cookies

Why Choose a Boxed Brownie Mix for Caramel Brownies?

While I love a good scratch recipe, there are undeniable advantages to using a boxed brownie mix for these caramel masterpieces:

• **Convenience:** Boxed mixes drastically cut down on prep time. No need to measure out flour, cocoa powder, sugar, and leavening agents – it’s all there, perfectly pre-portioned.
• **Consistency:** Mixes are formulated for reliable results. You can almost always count on a fudgy, chewy brownie base, which is ideal for supporting a rich caramel layer.
• **Accessibility:** A great option for beginner bakers or for those busy days when you want a delicious treat without all the fuss.
• **Variety:** With so many brownie mix brands available, you can experiment with different chocolate intensities and textures to find your perfect base.

Tips for Achieving the Perfect Layered Caramel Brownies

To ensure your boxed brownie mix caramel brownies turn out absolutely flawless every time, keep these expert tips in mind:

• **Don’t Rush Cooling:** The most critical step is ensuring the first brownie layer is completely cold, preferably chilled in the freezer. This prevents the warm caramel from melting into the brownie or becoming too runny.
• **Grease and Line Your Pan:** Always line your 8-inch square pan with nonstick foil or parchment paper, leaving an overhang on the sides. This makes lifting the entire brownie slab out for easy cutting a breeze.
• **Mind the Caramel Border:** When spreading the caramel, ensure you leave that ½-inch border from the pan edges. Caramel tends to spread during baking, and this prevents it from seeping under the bottom layer and potentially burning.
• **Gentle Spreading:** When spreading the top layer of brownie batter over the firm caramel, do so gently and evenly. You can dollop spoonfuls of batter and then carefully spread them with an offset spatula or the back of a spoon to avoid disturbing the caramel.
• **Low and Slow Baking:** Baking at 325°F (160°C) is key for thick, layered brownies. It allows the heat to penetrate evenly, cooking the center without drying out the edges or scorching the caramel.
• **Trust the Thermometer:** For ultimate precision, an instant-read thermometer is your best friend. Look for an internal temperature of 200-210°F (93-99°C) for fudgy brownies.

Customizing Your Caramel Brownies

This recipe is wonderfully adaptable! Here are a few ideas to make these caramel brownies truly your own:

• **Nut Variations:** Not a fan of pecans? Try walnuts, almonds, or even chopped peanuts for a different crunch.
• **Chocolate Boost:** Add extra chocolate chips to both the brownie batter and sprinkled on top for an intense chocolate experience. White chocolate chips would also be a fantastic addition to the top layer.
• **Spice It Up:** A pinch of cinnamon or a tiny dash of cayenne pepper in the brownie batter can add a warm, surprising depth of flavor.
• **Different Salts:** Experiment with different types of sea salt – a smoked sea salt would add a unique savory note to the sweet caramel.
• **No Pecans? No Problem!** If you prefer your caramel smooth, simply omit the pecans from the caramel layer.

Storage and Serving Suggestions

These caramel brownies are best enjoyed at room temperature or slightly warm. Store them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 3-4 days. For longer storage, you can freeze individual squares, tightly wrapped in plastic wrap and then foil, for up to 2-3 months. Thaw at room temperature or gently warm in the microwave for a few seconds.

Serve these decadent squares as is, or elevate them with a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream and an extra drizzle of caramel sauce. They’re also perfect alongside a hot cup of coffee or a cold glass of milk for an indulgent snack or dessert.

Common Questions & Troubleshooting

• **Why is my caramel hard after baking?** This often happens if the caramel is overcooked initially or if there isn’t enough cream added to it. Ensure you melt it gently and incorporate the full amount of heavy cream.
• **Why are my brownies too gooey?** If they’re *too* gooey (beyond fudgy), they might be underbaked. Refer to the internal temperature check in the recipe instructions. If they’re slightly gooey, it could be the specific brownie mix, or simply a matter of preference; some love an extra-gooey brownie!
• **My caramel seeped to the edges!** This usually means the caramel was spread too close to the pan’s edges, or the brownie base wasn’t cold enough, causing the caramel to become too liquid during baking. Next time, ensure that ½-inch border and thorough chilling.

Recipe